Seattle Municipal Court Redefines Fairness With the People It Serves

Client: Seattle Municipal Court (SMC)
Services:
Research · Strategy · Creative · Community Engagement · Reporting
Sector:
Public Sector / Criminal Legal System

Executive Summary

Seattle Municipal Court wanted to know what fairness and equity mean to the people who come before it. Vida asked them directly. Fifty-seven community members joined focus groups, and their findings led SMC to bring Vida back. Vida then led race and social justice training circles for judges and leadership, healing circles with impacted community members, and a court-wide process to refine SMC's values. SMC went on to create and staff a dedicated community engagement team to carry the work forward.

Introduction

Seattle Municipal Court handles criminal cases, traffic and parking violations, and jury service for the city. For many residents, it is their main contact with the justice system. SMC set out to improve equity, fairness, and accessibility, and to do it with the people most affected, not just about them. 

That meant hearing from people who rarely shape court policy: residents with criminal cases, residents with traffic or parking tickets, and jurors. BIPOC residents were a priority, because they are disproportionately affected by the criminal legal system. It also meant changing how the court itself makes decisions.

The process: How we built belonging 

‍ L - Local Insight 

A gap between fairness and experience 

People's idea of a fair court and their actual experience at court were often far apart. SMC could not close that gap without understanding it from the community's side. And lasting change would require judges and leadership to see the system through community eyes. 

O - Observation 

Asking people what a fair court looks like 

Vida recruited participants through outbound phone calls and mailers to people who had interacted with SMC in the past year, with priority registration for BIPOC participants. Of 131 people who responded, 72 were confirmed as eligible. Vida screened for a diverse range of perspectives and prepared each participant by phone and email. Every participant received an honorarium. 

When COVID-19 hit, the focus groups moved online. Fifty-seven people took part in five virtual sessions: 

  • Two groups with people who had criminal cases (20 participants) 

  • Two groups with people who had traffic, parking, or moving violations (21 participants) 

  • One group with people who served on an SMC jury (16 participants) 

Participants described what a fair and equitable court means to them, what that experience should feel like, and where SMC fell short. Vida delivered a findings report covering participant demographics, case contexts, common themes, participant quotes, and community-defined definitions of equity. 

C - Co-Creation 

From listening to changing the court 

After the report, SMC re-engaged Vida to put the findings to work. Vida facilitated race and social justice training circles for judges and leadership staff. The circles explored race, bias, and systemic inequity, and strengthened how leaders make decisions. 

Judges and leadership then joined pilot healing circles with community members who had been disproportionately affected by the criminal legal system. The circles created safe space for honest dialogue and trust across very different experiences. 

Building on those conversations, Vida guided judges and leadership through a participatory process to refine the court's institutional values. A staff survey, town hall meetings, and collaborative dialogue aligned the values with SMC's equity commitments and translated them into daily practice. 

A - Amplification 

Making the court easier to understand 

Vida also helped SMC communicate more clearly with the public. In 2023, Vida produced three plain-language explainer videos, now featured on the court's website and social media: 

  • Tickets: Options for parking, traffic, and camera tickets, and next steps. 

  • Probation: how probation works and what to expect. 

  • Criminal Court: How criminal cases are filed and move from filing to resolution. 

L - Lasting Impact 

Equity built into the institution 

SMC refined its institutional values and integrated equity into everyday practice. Vida developed sustainable engagement protocols for ongoing collaboration with the community. SMC then created and staffed a dedicated community engagement team to carry the work forward. 

“I am grateful to have a partner like [Vida]. Marcela has been instrumental in helping the Seattle Municipal Court imagine and implement our community engagement strategy. She is a trusted guide, teacher, and the catalyst we needed to step outside of our institution, listen to, and invite community into our work”

- Gary Ireland, Deputy Court Administrator, Strategy.  

Results: Real results, measurable impact 

  • 131 community members responded to recruitment; 72 confirmed; 57 participated 

  • 5 virtual focus groups with people who had criminal cases, traffic or parking violations, or jury service 

  • Race and social justice training circles for judges and leadership staff 

  • Pilot healing circles between court leaders and disproportionately impacted community members 

  • Court values refined through a staff survey and town halls 

  • SMC created and staffed a dedicated community engagement team 

  • 3 plain-language explainer videos on tickets, probation, and criminal court  

Conclusion: Local impact, anywhere. 

A court cannot define fairness on its own. Seattle Municipal Court asked the people it serves, then let what it heard change how judges lead, what the institution values, and who it hires to keep listening. That is how we work: community insight is the start of the change, not the end of the report.

Next
Next

Seattle's Farm to Table Defines Equitable Food Access With Community